Panzerungsschwellenwerte

Diese Seite wird derzeit von comcode3 bearbeitet.
Bitte verändere nichts an dieser Seite ohne comcode3 zu kontaktieren, solange diese Seite nicht fertiggestellt wurde!

Benutze die Diskussionsseite um wichtige Anmerkungen einzubringen.

Diese Warnung wurde am 14. Oktober 2020 erstellt.

HE-Penetration

In der folgenden Tabelle sind übliche Panzerungsstärken und das zugehörige für eine Penetration notwendige Kaliber von HE-Granaten aufgeführt, unter Berücksichtigung der Formel zur Berechnung eines HE-Durchschlags.

Ebenso werden die in Update 0.9.2 eingeführten Änderungen an der Fertigkeit "Trägheitszünder für Sprenggranaten" berücksichtigt. Das Meistern dieser Kapitänsfertigkeit halbiert nun die Wahrscheinlichkeit, ein gegnerisches Schiff in Brand zu stecken. Für Schiffe, die hauptsächlich auf Brandschaden setzen, bringt dies einen erheblichen Nachteil mit sich, auch wenn damit wichtige Panzerungsschwellenwerte durchschlagen werden können.

Ein englischsprachiger Forumpost von LittleWhiteMouse behandelt die Effektivität und Rentabilität des IFHE-Skills für verschiedene Geschützkaliber, was als Anhaltspunkt für die eigene Kapitänsskillung verwendet werden kann.

1/6, 1/5 und 1/4 sind die Penetrationskoeffizienten der HE-Granaten - "Eine HE-Granate durchschlägt Panzerungen bis zu 1/6 seines Durchmessers"
Die einzelnen Koeffizienten für bestimmte Schiffe können aus der entsprechenden Tabelle entnommen werden.

Panzerungsstärke (mm)	notwendiger HE-Granatendurchmesser für eine Penetration (mm)
	1/6	1/6 mit IFHE	1/5	1/5 mit IFHE	1/4	1/4 mit IFHE
13	75	63	62.5	52.5	50	42
16	93	75	77.5	62.5	62	50
19	111	93	92.5	77.5	74	62
20	117	93	97.5	77.5	78	62
25	147	117	122.5	97.5	98	78
26	153	123	127.5	102.5	102	82
27	159	129	132.5	107.5	106	86
30	177	141	147.5	117.5	118	94
32	189	153	157.5	127.5	126	102
38	225	183	187.5	152.5	150	122
40	237	189	197.5	157.5	158	126
50	297	237	247.5	197.5	198	158
51	303	243	252.5	202.5	202	162
60	357	285	297.5	237.5	238	190

HE penetration (before Update 0.9.2)

OLD INFORMATION AS PER UPDATE 0.9.2. NEW INFORMATION IS UNDER CONSTRUCTION. THE UPDATE IS QUITE COMPLEX, SOME TIME IS NEEDED TO PROCESS ALL CHANGES.

Here are some common armor thicknesses and the minimum HE shell diameters needed to penetrate them, according to the HE penetration formula. "Super" refers to the 1/4 HE penetration coefficient.

By armor thickness

Armor thickness	Occurrences (non-exhaustive)	Beneficiaries (without IFHE) (non-exhaustive)	Beneficiaries (with IFHE) (non-exhaustive)
16 mm	Tier 3 battleship bow/stern Tier 6 - 7 battleship superstructure Most tier 6 - 7 cruiser bow/stern The entirety of British light cruiser and Smolensk hull plating Tier 6 - 7 destroyer plating	All guns of 114 mm or more calibre
19 mm	Tier 4 - 5 battleship bow/stern Tier 6 - 7 light cruiser side plating Tier 8 - 10 battleship superstructure Tier 8 - 10 destroyer plating	All guns of 114 mm or more calibre
25 mm	Tier 6 and 7 cruisers' decks, most tier 8 - 10 cruisers' bow/stern, tier 8 - 10 light cruisers' side plating	Heavy cruisers (203mm) Light cruisers (155mm) Japanese 100 mm guns German 105 mm secondary guns	Most destroyers (120 mm - 150 mm)
26 mm	Tier 6 and 7 battleship bow/stern and some of their casemate plating	Heavy cruisers (203 mm) Light cruisers (180 mm, T8+ 152/155 mm) Japanese 100 mm guns German 105 - 150 mm guns	Light cruisers (152mm) up to and including tier 7 Most destroyers (127 mm - 139 mm)
27 mm	Tier 8 and 9 cruiser decks, some tier 8 - 10 cruiser bow/stern (USN and German heavy cruisers)	Heavy cruisers (203 mm) Light cruisers (tier 8 - 10 152 - 155 mm, 180 mm) Japanese 100 mm guns German 128 - 150 mm guns	Light cruisers (152mm) up to and including tier 7 Some destroyers (130 mm - 139 mm, 100 mm super)
30 mm	Most tier 10 cruiser deck plating, most tier 10 heavy cruiser side plating, Ägir, Siegfried, Albemarle and Drake deck plating	Heavy cruisers (203 mm), tier 8 - 10 light cruisers (152, 155, 180 mm) Japanese 100 mm guns German 128 - 150 mm guns	Tier 7 and lower light cruisers (152 mm, 155 mm, 180 mm) Donskoi and Molotov (180mm)
32 mm	Tier 8 - 10 battleship bow/stern, tier 8 - 10 British and French battleships' casemate plating, Slava deck plating	Heavy cruisers (203 mm) German 128 - 150 mm guns (both main and secondary)	Most light cruisers (152 mm, 155 mm, 180 mm) Japanese 100 mm guns
38 mm	Tier 8 - 10 USN battleship decks	Henri IV (240 mm) Goliath (234 mm) Superheavy cruisers (305 - 310 mm) All german cruisers German 150 mm guns	All non-German 203 mm ships, and Mogami. Not worth it on 203mm guns, since you lose a lot fire chance just to penetrate this category of armor.
50 mm	Khabarovsk belt Moskva, Stalingrad and Petropavlovsk casemate plating Tier 7 - 10 German battleships' decks	German 203 mm (Hindenburg, Roon, Hipper, Yorck) Superheavy cruisers (305 - 310 mm)	Henri IV (240 mm) (not worth it, considering how much fire chance you lose)
60 mm	Sovetsky Soyuz, AL Sov. Rossiya and Kremlin deck	Only battleship calibre HE can penetrate their deck armor	German 203 mm (Hindenburg, Roon, Hipper, Yorck) Superheavy cruisers (305 - 310 mm), but it's not worth speccing into IFHE considering how much fire chance you lose

By HE diameter

HE shell	Occurrences (non-exhaustive)	Maximum armor thickness penetrated		IFHE beneficial against (non-exhaustive)
		Without IFHE	With IFHE
Tier 8 - 10 152 mm 180 mm Japanese 100 mm	Most light cruisers Some Japanese destroyers/secondaries	30 mm	32 mm	Tier 8 - 10 battleship bow/stern, tier 8 - 10 British and French battleships' casemate plating, Slava deck plating
419-420 mm with improved HE penetration	Conqueror, Friedrich der Große, Großer Kurfürst, Lion	104 mm	136 mm	Citadels: Cleveland, Edinburgh, Fiji, Helena, New Orleans, Worcester

Notes

• As per the tables above, 152 mm and 155 mm HE, primarily found on light cruisers; and 100 mm HE, found on Japanese gunboat destroyers and some secondary batteries, are by far the biggest beneficiaries.
• 180 mm HE benefits less from IFHE because of a more drastic relative reduction in fire chance for not much gain in both absolute and impactful damage output
• The only secondary weaponst that may benefit from IFHE are German 105 mm secondaries with 26 mm base penetration, however, they give up a lot of fire chance for the ability to penetrate up to and including 32 mm plating, which is most of the time not worth it
• Some other ships gain some benefit, but this is not generally considered worth the cost in skill points and the tradeoff in fire starting capabilities.

AP overmatch

An AP shell whose diameter is greater than 14.3 times the thickness of an armor plate will overmatch and pass through it regardless of angle. Here are some thresholds where this occurs, which determines whether it is feasible to "bow-tank" a particular AP shell.

Armor thickness	AP shell diameter needed to overmatch	Occurrences (non-exhaustive)	Notes
10 mm	144 mm	Tier 4-5 cruiser superstructure Tier 4-5 destroyer plating	Will bounce most destroyer shells if sufficiently angled, but not most light cruiser shells.
13 mm	186 mm	Tier 4 - 5 battleship superstructure Tier 4 and 5 cruiser bow/stern Most tier 6 - 7 cruiser superstructure	Will bounce light cruiser shells if sufficiently angled but not heavy cruiser shells (203 mm).
16 mm	229 mm	Tier 3 battleship bow/stern Tier 6 - 7 battleship superstructure Most tier 6 - 7 cruiser bow/stern The entirety of British light cruiser and Smolensk hull plating Tier 6 - 7 destroyer plating	Will bounce almost all cruiser shells if sufficiently angled. Notable: Can bounce Moskva (220 mm) but not Henri IV (240 mm), Graf Spee or Scharnhorst (283 mm).
19 mm	272 mm	Tier 4 - 5 battleship bow/stern Tier 6 - 7 light cruiser side plating Tier 8 - 10 battleship superstructure Tier 8 - 10 destroyer plating	Will bounce up to 254 mm AP if sufficiently angled. Notable: Can bounce Henri IV (240 mm), but not Graf Spee, Scharnhorst (283 mm) and battlecruiser AP shells (305 - 310 mm).
25 mm	358 mm	Tier 6 and 7 cruisers' decks, most tier 8 - 10 cruisers' bow/stern, tier 8 - 10 light cruisers' side plating	Will bounce up to 14-inch shells (356 mm) if sufficiently angled.
26 mm	371 mm	Tier 6 and 7 battleship bow/stern and some of their casemate plating	Will bounce up to 15-inch shells (381 mm) if sufficiently angled.
27 mm	387 mm	Tier 8 and 9 cruiser decks, some tier 8 - 10 cruiser bow/stern (USN and German heavy cruisers)	Will bounce up to 15-inch shells (381 mm) if sufficiently angled.
30 mm	430 mm	Most tier 10 cruiser deck plating, most tier 10 heavy cruiser side plating, Ägir, Siegfried, Albemarle and Drake deck plating	At current only Thunderer (457 mm), Georgia (457 mm), Ohio (457 mm), Kremlin (457 mm), Musashi (460 mm), République (431 mm), Yamato (460 mm), and Shikishima (510 mm) can overmatch.
32 mm	458 mm	Tier 8-10 battleship bow/stern, tier 8 - 10 British and French battleships' casemate plating, Slava deck plating	At current only Musashi, Yamato (both 460 mm), and Shikishima (510 mm) can overmatch.